A policy at war with itself, judge bork maintained that antitrust enforcement had overzealously applied the law in a manner that led to the protection of inefficient. The paradox of antitrust enforcement was that legal intervention artificially raised prices by protecting inefficient enterprises from competition. Rabeux louise rated it it was amazing feb 03, the book was cited by over a hundred courts. This page was last edited on 5 decemberat views read edit view history. The panel pointed out that robert bork had described lorain journal as entirely correct in his famous book the antitrust paradox. He also became an influential antitrust scholar, arguing that consumers often benefited from corporate mergers and that antitrust law should focus on consumer welfare rather than on ensuring competition. Bork article the antitrust paradox by robert h bork regulating competition. The antitrust paradox changed the direction of antitrust law by systematically applying economic analysis to the legal issues that face courts in antitrust litigation.
Aug 04, 2019 the antitrust paradox is a book by robert bork that criticized the state of united states antitrust law in the s. Mar 22, 2008 27 quoting borks 1978 book, the antitrust paradox, of which his 1966 thesis was a small but important part, the court declared that the legislative history suggests that congress designed the sherman act as a consumer welfare prescription. The antitrust paradox is the most important book on antitrust ever written. Judge borks early writings in antitrust were a major contribution to the development of the chicago school of antitrust analysis. The rise and fall of information empires, published in 2010, he was drawn more deeply into antitrust law. Whatever the present utility of his views, bork makes a formidible and respectable defense of judicial formalism a theory that views the role of the judge as extremely limited. This is from a speech a judge named robert bork gave in 1987. Is the platform economy forcing us to reconsider antitrust. Generational impact of the antitrust 2018 antitrust paradox.
A look at kavanaughs approach to antitrust law law360. The antitrust paradox,l into the context of the chicago schools contribution to the modem direction. Its difficult to capture in just a few paragraphs the legacy of judge bork, who died wednesday at age 85. It is a scholarly, yet accessible, examination of the nations antitrust laws, the history and policies behind them, and their application from their inception to today. In competition law today, though there are differences, all follow bork. Perhaps we will differ on the interpretation of him but. The central, pragmatic thesis of bork is maximization of consumer welfare also called economic efficiency and not the protection of small businesses in addressing any antitrust issue. A second edition, updated to reflect substantial changes in the law, was published in 1993. Jun 29, 2018 a conference celebrating the 40th anniversary of the honorable judge robert borks book the antitrust paradox took place on june 22nd at the capitol hill club in washington, dc. Bork wrote several notable books, including the antitrust paradox. By the time of the antitrust paradoxs second edition in 1993, the book s analysis was of primarily historical interest.
Mar 22, 2008 9 these ideas are also a foundation of the antitrust paradox, but the book extends the analysis of antitrust law substantially beyond ideas relating to vertical practices. Any antitrust person would tell you the same thing. Judge kavanaugh is a bright, energetic, aggressive devotee of the chicago school of antitrust, said calkins, who is on the american antitrust. Jun 29, 2018 2018 antitrust paradox conference a conference celebrating the 40th anniversary of the honorable judge robert borks book the antitrust paradox took place on june 22nd at the capitol hill club. And leaving aside the theoretical expressions and implications of borks many wri by now, other wise writers have an exposed and thoroughly discredited the tragic unpragmatism of robert borks formalist legal theory. Antitrust paradox conference the federalist society.
Judge borks 1987 nomination to the supreme court was rejected by the senate, not on qualifications but on judicial philosophy and temperament. Be the first to ask a question about antitrust paradox. She studied the book industry, then the chickenfarming industry. Through the book and the policies advanced in it, judge. Eric zepp rated it it was ok dec 08, board of regents of univ. Dec 20, 2012 judge borks 1987 nomination to the supreme court was rejected by the senate, not on qualifications but on judicial philosophy and temperament. Robert bork, the antitrust paradox valposcholar valparaiso. Borks strategy and the influence of the chicago school on. In 1978, judge robert bork published the book the antitrust paradox. The thesis of the book was that the courts, and particularly the supreme court, had made an incoherent mush of. The theme of former solicitor general bork s book is that the antitrust laws should be concerned with maintaining competition, not with protecting individual competitors.
Judge borks work led antitrust enforcement to focus on economic efficiency and consumer welfare rather than effects on competitors. He wrote a book called the antitrust paradox that argued antitrust enforcement had gotten out of hand and the government needed to. Since 1992 game theory has frequently been used in antitrust. The short answer is that judge borks views on competition and antitrust, best expressed in his 1978 the antitrust paradox, found immediate purchase in the corridors of power. Leif rated it really liked it nov 04, in these tasks, borks skills as a lawyer and thinker are beyond reproach. The antitrust paradox tue a book by robert bork that nork the state of united states antitrust law in the s. T he case on pages 344 and 345 of the antitrust paradox is indeed the only thing in borks 462 page book that even faintly supports his current position. Through the book and the policies advanced in it, judge bork has had a profound impact on antitrust scholarship and practice. It has been 40 years since judge robert bork published his influential book, the antitrust paradox. A conference celebrating the 40th anniversary of the honorable judge robert borks book the antitrust paradox took place on june 22nd at the capitol hill club in washington, dc. Since it first appeared in 1978, this seminal work by one of the foremost legal minds of our age has dramatically changed the way the courts view governments role in private affairs. Important book that transformed the nations antitrust law.
Jun 22, 2018 in 1978, judge robert bork published the book the antitrust paradox. Since 1992 game theory has frequently been used in antitrust cases. Now reissued with a new introduction and eiplogue by the author, this classic shows how antitrust suits adversely affect the consumer by encouraging a costly form of protection for inefficient and uncompetitive. The antitrust paradox is a book by robert bork that criticized the state of united states antitrust law in the s. Bork argued that what should really matter is not a companys market share, but. Zach rated it liked it dec 07, originalist robert bork wrote an article in that looked at the legislative intent of the sherman act to limit the scope of antitrust. At yale he was best known for writing the antitrust paradox, a book in which he argued that consumers often benefited from corporate mergers, and that many thencurrent readings of the antitrust laws were economically irrational and hurt consumers. The abiding influence of the antitrust paradox yale law school. In addition to being a retailer, it is now a marketing platform, a delivery and logistics network, a payment service, a credit lender, an auction house, a major book publisher, a producer of television and. Easterbrook wrote a brief, in that he wrote the point of antitrust is consumer welfare, the phrase from the antitrust paradox. Bork has served as solicitor general and acting attorney general of the united states, and as a united states court of appeals judge. Seventh circuit revives monopolization and tying agreement. Tsvetelin tsonevski rated it it was amazing feb 22, miguel sotomayor rated it really liked it sep 12, by now, other wise writers have an exposed and thoroughly discredited the tragic unpragmatism of robert borks formalist legal.
The paradox is variously applied to a prisoners hanging, or a surprise school test. A former professor of law at yale law school, he is currently a professor at ave maria school of law, a senior fellow at the american enterprise institute, and the tad and dianne taube distinguished visiting. This book is a summary and extension of his earlier work, and a trenchant critique of the antitrust jurisprudence of the warren court. The antitrust paradox 1978, is a beautifully written book, but he added virtually nothing new or original to the well. Jun 17, 2019 rabeux louise rated it it was amazing feb 03, the book was cited by over a hundred courts. Frank easterbrook, now a federal appeals court judge, was at the time deputy solicitor general. Then there was a backlash led by a judge named robert bork. Quest row shows high courts antitrust paradox, judge says. Forty years ago, robert bork published his influential book the antitrust paradox. Lina khan and the hipster antitrust movement the atlantic. Except when responding to advertisements and sale promotions, the people are stupid. Donohue, professor in the northwestern university school of law and a research fellow at the american bar foundation.
And leaving aside the theoretical expressions and implications of bork s many wri by now, other wise writers have an exposed and thoroughly discredited the tragic unpragmatism of robert bork s formalist legal theory. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. The antitrust paradox has become one of the most influential authorities on antitrust policy, changing the landscape of american antitrust law forever. The antitrust paradox illustrates how the purpose and integrity of law. Oct 20, 2012 this is the summary of antitrust paradox by robert h.
This brief essay seeks to place judge borks important book. The antitrust laws were passed and began to be enforced at a time when americans were going through one of their bouts of especially intense criticism of the nations business structure and practice. Oct 24, 2019 that started to change in 1978, with the publication of an important book by robert bork, the antitrust paradox. It is claimed that the work is the most cited book on antitrust. Since its publication, the antitrust paradox has been cited by over 100 different united states courts, and its reasoning has often been adopted by the supreme court of the. His work in antitrust law was so influentialit reshaped the way that the entire legal profession thought about the discipline, and his book the antitrust paradox was listed as one of the most significant books of the last centurythat this accomplishment alone would have merited his inclusion in the list of modern legal luminaries. Shows how antitrust suits adversely affect the consumer by enc. The unexpected hanging paradox or surprise test paradox is a paradox about a persons expectations about the timing of a future event which they are told will occur at an unexpected time. The antitrust paradox is a 1978 book by robert bork that criticized the state of united states antitrust law in the 1970s. In the four decades since the publication of the antitrust paradox, corporate concentration has remade nearly every corner of the u. In the antitrust paradox, bork wrote, the real danger for the law is less that predation will be missed than that normal competitive behavior will be wrongly classified as predatory and suppressed. Click download or read online button to get antitrust paradox book now. The paradox how robert bork won the fight over the very meaning of.
He expanded upon this in articles and the book, the antitrust paradox, in 1978. With the rise of antitrust enforcement regimes around the world as well as the rise of big technology companies the legacy of the antitrust paradox is now being challenged in the united states and abroad. Sep 26, 2018 it has been 40 years since judge robert bork published his influential book, the antitrust paradox. Jeff rated it really liked it jan 16, scott wood rated it it was amazing oct 16, one of the key criticisms focuses on borks use of the term consumer welfare, which became the stated goal of american antitrust. There is no consensus on its precise nature and consequently a canonical resolution has not been agreed on. Generational impact of the antitrust 2018 antitrust. Bork the antitrust paradox pdf search for happiness. Opening remarks 2018 antitrust paradox conference youtube.
Yet damned if he didnt start to convince me that his views were better as i read the antitrust paradox. Dec 11, 2019 while researching his second book, the master switch. Antitrust paradox download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Since its publication, the antitrust paradox has been cited by over 100 different united states courts, and its reasoning has. The paradox, therefore, was that while preventing certain mergers and exclusionary arrangements might have appeared to. C utting prices in order to increase business often is the. By the time of the antitrust paradox s second edition in 1993, the book s analysis was of primarily historical interest. He posited that the primary focus of antitrust laws should be on consumer. Virtually all would agree that the supreme court, in its change of direc tion of antitrust law beginning in the late 1970s, drew princi pally from judge borksbookbothfor guidance and supportof. Bork argued that antitrust enforcement prevented exclusionary dealslike vertical mergersthat would have increased efficiency.
1211 311 1130 1457 653 988 1262 505 306 173 358 263 682 989 1450 828 618 1396 912 986 185 1374 234 1587 611 815 476 498 1021 112 410 299 11 127 1082 471