A passage from a book chapter written by one of the most distinguished mormon thinkers of the last 50 years tells a story so much like mine that i must quote it. Nearly twenty years ago, as a firstyear graduate student at the university of california, berkeley, my ambition was to become another hugh nibley, whose writings i had loved since i was twelve. Jul 07, 2005 ed firmage, for many years the token mormon at the u of u law school, is an interesting apostate. Nancy ashments husband ed is an egyptologist and the author of the book of abraham facsimiles. Oct, 2008 the book of mormon is part of the work and a wonder. Mosiah priority is a theory about the creation of the book of mormon arguing that the original manuscript began not with 1 nephi found at the beginning of the book of mormon, but midway through, starting with mosiah. In particular, old testament prophetic teachings are examined, as distinguished from israels experience in the conquest of canaan through the davidic monarchy, teachings of jesus on force and violence.
Wright proposes a modern source, the king james version, for. According to mosiah priority, after the text of mosiah through the end of the book of mormon was transcribed, joseph smith returned to the beginning and. Firmage begins by explaining some of the problems with the historicity of the book and reaches a conclusion that the book of mormon is most likely not an ancient document. New approaches to the book of mormon signature books. The anthology begins notably well, with edwin firmage jr. What set him off was what he saw as its trivialization of the history of.
The edwin brown firmage papers 1780 2014 consist of speeches, essays, articles, book drafts, notes, correspondence, news letters, pamphlets, and reports, among other papers, surrounding firmages vast interests. Roberts is also outstanding, documenting how roberts publicly championed the book of mormon but privately experienced misgivings about its authenticity as an ancient text. Mosiah priority is the most widely held solution to questions regarding the sequence of the english text. What it means to take upon the name of jesus christ. Firmage is a former professor of international and constitutional law at the university of utah. Positivism and the priority of ideology in mosiahfirst. Firmage teaches constitutional and international law at the. Another look at the book of mormon, sunstone 10 june 1985. Miraculous origins theories generally accept joseph smiths own account, that he translated an ancient record compiled and abridged by mormon, a precolumbian resident of the western hemisphere. Firmage and mangrum have skillfully used the church court records to offer an intimate portrayal of the nature of early mormon communities. Edwin brown firmage and richard collin mangrum pub date.
Other contributors to american apocrypha explore the evolution of ideas in the book of mormon during the course of its dictation. Paul and the expansion of the church today by edwin brown firmage 71 pages if we were to try to attach a slogan to the missionary effort of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints today, it might well be president spencer w. Welch, jacobs ten commandments, in reexploring the book of mormon. Firmage this is a study of religious teachings on force and war as they apply in the nuclear age. These teachings may be more important now than ever. According to mosiah priority, after the text of mosiah through the end of the book of mormon was transcribed, joseph smith returned to the beginning and transcribed 1 nephi through words of mormon. An introduction davis bitton, val lambson, lowell c. He has also practiced law both in his native california and in utah. Firmage seems to have been really upset by the doctrine of apostasy. Why joseph smith wrote the book of mormon, republished in 1992 by signature books, robert hullinger depicts joseph as a defender of godomotivated by the noble desire to defend revealed religion against the inroads of deism.
Edwin brown firmage probing the high prevalence of polygyny in st. Born in utah, brown held both american and canadian citizenship brown was a talented speaker, and was well known for. Firmage and mangrum have skillfully used the church court records to offer an intimate portrayal of the nature of early mormon communities and doctrines. Automaticity and the dictation of the book of mormon scott c.
Welch, counting to ten, journal of book of mormon studies 12, no. Essays on the book of mormon essays on mormonism, on librarything librarything is a cataloging and social networking site for booklovers home groups talk zeitgeist. Automaticity and the dictation of the book of mormon. The teachings of the old testament, the new testament, and the book of mormon, byu studies quarterly.
May 12, 2011 a passage from a book chapter written by one of the most distinguished mormon thinkers of the last 50 years tells a story so much like mine that i must quote it. Ed firmage, for many years the token mormon at the u of u law school, is an interesting apostate. Edwin b firmage ed an abundant life the memoirs of byu studies. While providing a perceptive analysis of positions taken in the courts by mormon leaders against repressive federal legislation, the authors have also presented a revealing glimpse of the development of a church court system to deal with contentious issues arising at all levels in the mormon society. Firmage won many awards and honors for his humanitarian crusades, including utah edowment for the humanities governors award, the university of utah distinguished teaching award, the charles redd prize, and many others. There are differing views on the origin of the book of mormon. May 15, 2002 to be brief, ill just point to the essay by professor edwin firmage, who tells a compelling story of how he came to abandon his belief that the book of mormon is an ancient document. The inability of american society to tolerate the peculiar institutions embraced by mormons was one of the major events in the religious history of nineteenthcentury america. What set him off was what he saw as its trivialization of the history of christian thought. Paul and the expansion of the church today by edwin brown. New approaches to the book of mormon explorations in critical methodology edited by brent lee metcalfe. This weekend i read his deconversion story and was struck by an interesting twist on the familiar litinany of mormon failures.
Although much of the collection deals with international and constitutional. Firmage and mangrum have skillfully used the church court records to offer an intimate portrayal. A journal of mormon thought, volume 30 number 4, winter 1997. Resources to help you immerse yourself in the restoration. Dunn lamanite genesis, genealogy, and genetics thomas w. A legal history of the church of jesus christ of latter. A gift from ed firmage university of utah professor emeritus to the rare books department raises intriguing questions. Professor firmages book with collin mangrum, zion in the courts. Youth invited to join face to face event with president and sister oaks. Items do not represent the official views of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints or of book of mormon central. Variations of this theory only include that the text is a divinely inspired narrative, regardless of. The other essays in this book are also fascinating. The book of mormon is part of the work and a wonder. A legal history of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints, 18301900 edwin brown firmage, richard collin mangrum university of illinois press, 2001 religion 430 pages.
Utah artist and author of the essay historical criticism and the book of mormon. He was a member of the churchs quorum of the twelve apostles and first presidency. I ntroduction a united nations study estimates that the direct effects of an allout nuclear exchangethe initial blasts, the consequent radiation, and the ensuing. The edwin brown firmage papers 1780 20 consist of speeches, essays, articles, book drafts, notes, correspondence, news letters, pamphlets, and reports, among other papers, surrounding firmages vast interests. A legal history of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints, 18301900 1st first edition hardcover at. Firmage, edwin brown social networks and archival context. Hugh brown brown october 24, 1883 december 2, 1975 was an attorney, educator, author and leader in the church of jesus christ of latterday saints lds church. Daynes demographic limits of nineteenthcentury mormon polygyny davis bitton and val lambson mapping the extent of plural marriage in st. Wright proposes a modern source, the king james version, for the isaiah passages in the book of mormon. Zion in the courts explores one aspect of this collision between the mormons and the mainstream. It is from edwin firmage, a truly distinguished law professor at the university of utah and grandson of the beloved mormon leader hugh b. George smiths article on early 20thcentury lds leader brigham h. Ui press edwin brown firmage and richard collin mangrum.
Young includes memoirs concerning many of the prominent early lds church leaders in utah. Price, the book of mormonall essentially for the first time with any seriousness. I think behind every great religious figure, theres probably not a little charlatan. Dunns essays appeared previously in sunstone magazine see firmage, historical criticism and the book of mormon. Nancy ashment nancy ashments husband ed is an egyptologist and the author of the book of abraham facsimiles. A reappraisal, and other works scrutinizing the supposedly ancient provenance of mormon scripture. Theres definitely a lot of shadow, and thats what makes them. To latterday saints there can be no objection to the careful and critical study of the scriptures, ancient or modern, provided only that it be an honest studya search for truth. Murphy the validity of the witnesses testimonies dan vogel b. The validity of the witnesses testimonies dan vogel 5.
Allof them culminate in asublime, transcendent message for our day. Paul and the expansion of the church today by edwin brown firmage. To be brief, ill just point to the essay by professor edwin firmage, who tells a compelling story of how he came to abandon his belief that the book of mormon is an ancient document. He holds a masters in ancient history and mediterranean studies from the university of california, berkeley and studied in the phd program of near eastern studies at hebrew university in jerusalem. In 1979, he established the foundation for ancient research and mormon studies farms, serving as its president until 1989 and as a member of its board of. Reuben clark law school of brigham young university. Choice a major work of scholarship which deserves close attention from those interested in the mormon encounter with american legal and cultural values. Firmage teaches constitutional and international law at the university of utahs college of law in salt lake city. Widtsoe, council of the twelve apostles, in search of truth. How you can join in the largest family history conference in the world.
611 589 1283 1077 414 791 234 838 1343 1263 648 1381 283 751 1500 1364 1356 710 111 1176 962 423 545 1293 1148 148 921 1488 1424 582 1516 157 1125 710 1285 1458 452 1354 87 314 1232 178